P&I pricing could rise 50% by 2024

Protection and indemnity (P&I) insurance premiums for shipowners could cost half as much again in four years’ time, according to Gallagher.

However, the impact in real terms will effectively amount to restoration of rates prevailing in 2016, thanks to the erosion wrought by systematic technical losses at almost all clubs over the last period, the leading broker adds.

The unwelcome news comes in addition to a marked recent jump in hull cover pricing, with a surge of at least 10% in the first half of the year and anecdotal evidence of increases of up to 20%, even for clean business.

“Combined ratios are averaging over 120%, so from a technical standpoint the market isn’t doing well,” Gallagher divisional director, Alex Vullo, said in an interview. “This is the second hard year in the current P&I cycle, but we’ve come off the back of what was arguably the softest period in P&I history, a seven-year soft cycle.

“During that time, rates fell anywhere between 30% and some cases 60% on average. It means clubs will have to claw back more even just to get back close to where they were.”

The calculations – based on compounding successive general increases and assuming a hefty hike in reinsurance costs – are derived from in-house analysis of financial statements published by International Group affiliate P&I clubs since 2016, especially their combined ratios.

They do not claim to be definitive, and the figures may contradict stated combined ratios published by the clubs themselves, which Gallagher believes tend to flatter the marine mutuals.

But the broker points out it is widely accepted there are different possible accounting treatments of the same figures.

There are also cases where a club does not divulge full information, or where diversification makes it hard to calculate a combined ratio for pure P&I activity.

In 2016, at the height of a soft market, 11 of the 13 International Group clubs recorded a combined ratio of below the breakeven point 100%, which is roughly where not-for-profit clubs want to be.

The outcomes ranged from 75% to 109%, and the average was 92%. However, luck is always an element, as results can be adversely affected by random major claims.

By 2017, the average had risen by ten percentage point to 102%; by 2018, the average had risen yet again by a further 10 points to 112%; in 2019, the average hit 115%, with all clubs over 100% and thus offsetting investment returns with underwriting losses. 

The 2020 average reached 122% – excluding the Japan Club, for which figures are not yet available. Even the best performers such as Gard and Shipowners were on 104% and the UK Club was an outlier on 150%.

Free reserves have effectively kept the show on the road. In 2016, free reserves aggregated $5.3bn, with all clubs booking growth in investment returns.

In 2017, free reserves grew by $433m, only to see a collective dip of $382m the following year, although just over a third of that was at UK club, which was faced with a hybrid bond repayment in that year.

There was growth of $186m in 2019 and effective breakeven in 2020, with a fractional gain of $2m despite the pandemic. In sum, free reserves last year were up by slightly less than 5% on 2016.

“Often clubs rely on investment returns to prop up the balance sheet. Over the past 20-odd years they’ve lost $1.6bn on underwriting, and then they’ve gained $2bn to 3bn on investment returns,” said Vullo.

But at the end of the day, all of this is shipowners’ money, and while some clubs may appear cash-rich, they are under pressure from regulators and ratings agencies to maintain solvency.

As a result of these trends, Gallagher is predicting high single-digit premium increases at the next renewal round, and perhaps up to 15% at the most pressured clubs.

Taking 4.8% as the actual average general increase in 2020, it predicts an average GI 7.4% in 2021, 9.3% in 2022, 10% in 2023 and 7.5% in 2024.

Meanwhile, the International Group pool scheme is currently up for renewal, and paying for cover on a per tonne basis is non-negotiable.

Pool claims tended to average 15 to 18 a year in past but have totalled 46 in the past two years alone.

Vullo cites market speculation of substantial rise after a string of major casualties culminating in Ever Given, and the reinsurance alone could put 5%-7% on premiums in some cases, depending on vessel type.

Compounded, that would make for an increase of 45.5%; throw in additional reinsurance premiums and that increase could ultimately come in at around 55%.

“Our 30% to 40% could be compounded to 40% to 50% quite easily if reinsurance rates are going to be added on top. At that point, shipowners are going to fight even harder to get a better deal for their P&I premium,” said Vullo.

“The shipowners we deal with are all sophisticated buyers. They read what’s going on and listen to our presentations. They are tough negotiators and they are good negotiators and they will fight very hard.”

Despite the big picture, Vullo does not expect more club hopping, and believes that owners will wait to see how things pan out before moving tonnage.

“Everyone is aware that the next three to four years will be a challenging P&I market in terms of rating. It’s just [down to] negotiating as hard as possible.”

This article first appeared in Lloyd's List, a sister publication of Insurance Day